I’ve been wanting to see The Bucket List for a while. Not too long as I didn’t find out about it until after it came out. The concept is great. An odd couple of cancer patients get stuck in the same room at a hospital. Eventually they start to get along, but then they get this idea to do a bucket list. A list of things that they want to do before they kick the bucket. So they go off on a grand adventure made possible by one of the guys being a billionaire.
Sounds brilliant, don’t it?
Unfortunately, something went wrong. It’s an okay movie, but it doesn’t rise above. It doesn’t meet its potential. It is too good for that ‘fellow’. Slight language warning on that link.
First problem is the characters. They are too much. Their main character traits are too exaggerated to make them truly likable. At times I like them, but much of the time their traits make them obnoxious. Despite this, Thomas, the billionaire’s attourney/aide, is awesome. He’s great. Perfect character.
Ed, the billionaire and Nicholson’s character, is a jerk. He’s a “I have money, what else do I need” type billionaire. A man who believes money can buy anything. Now, having a lot of money can quite easily lead to such a person. He loves the money. But his jerk level was too high. Much too high. I don’t care if their are people like that. I just can’t like the fellow when he’s that big of a jerk. His change of heart at the end doesn’t make him more likable. He is still so pushy and such a jerk that his likableness is permanantly damaged.
Carter, the poor mechanic and Freeman’s character, is a know-it-all. I don’t even have to mention why that’s annoying. That trait is worse than being a jerk. I think he was supposed to be a trivia buff. Having lots of obscure knowledge. That’s okay. But he always knows the answer. He always has just the right story. He always knows everything. He crosses the line from trivia buff to know-it-all. And by golly, that’s obnoxious. He’s an outright Mary Sue.
I’ve heard male versions of Mary Sue, Gary Gtu and Marty Stu being the big ones, but they lack the charm of the term Mary Sue. Besides, why do we need different terms for different sexes?
Next issue was that of time allocation. The movie spent way too much time ‘developing’ the characters in the hosipital setting before having them go on their grand adventure. They only had 100 minutes. The time should have been spent more on the adventure.
The initial character developement done in the hospital took too long. They did not need to spend half the movie establishing that Carter was a know-it-all with ‘faith’ and Ed was a materialist and a jerk. The real character developement happened on and after the trip.
The movie should have begun thus: introduce our characters and the fact that they are sick, give a little time (1 or 2 short scenes) with them in the hospital together, montage, introduce the bucket list, give the characters the news that they have only months to live, start journey. They could have done this in 10-15 minutes tops.
My final, and largest, complaint is that of ‘faith’. Carter talks about ‘faith’ at one point and I get the feeling that they were trying to give a message about the importance of ‘faith’. The problem lies in that it was a generic, undefined ‘faith’. I hate undefined ‘faith’. It’s meaningless garbage. If you want to talk faith talk specifics. Give me Buddhist, Muslim, druidistic, or something else specific before you feed me this undefined dreck.
But then, it’s a generic American movie for generic American people so why shouldn’t it have generic American faith?
I didn’t really enjoy it. It was okay. The problem that prevented me from enjoying it was the horrid flaws that were preventing it from being good. Flaws that could have very easily been fixed. It’s like they didn’t even try.
With a bit of effort, I think it could even have been very good.
Posted by marfresbo
Posted by marfresbo 